Yesterday, Hima Shamsi, our new National Security Project staff attorney, blogged on the Huffington Post about the
mistrial declared in the federal case against the Holy Land Foundation.
This case, Hima says, points to the problem of
flaws in the criminal material support statute - which could use a big overhaul:
Material support prosecutions criminalize guilt by association. Fundamental to this country’s conception of criminal responsibility is the requirement that, in the words of the Supreme Court, “guilt is personal.” In other words, we do not criminalize guilt by association. The material support statute and the government’s application of it, however, do just that by not requiring that the purpose of any support be unlawful.”
So even unwitting donors with only good intentions - like supporting humanitarian aid - can still be prosecuted for providing funds to groups the government believes is supporting terrorism.
The New York Times tackled the larger issue of the
government bringing misguided terrorism trials. According to the article, “scholars and former prosecutors say the government should have known better than to bring some of its recent failed cases and that a lack of selectivity and judgment, along with a reliance on stale evidence and links to groups not at the core of the current threat, may be harming the effort to combat terrorism.”
One important law in that regard is the prohibition on politically partisan activity. Given our nonprofit status, we may not endorse or oppose candidates for elective office. That means we cannot host comments on our site that show a preference for one candidate or party. Although we in no way wish to discourage you from that activity elsewhere, we ask that you not engage in that activity on our website (or include links to other websites that do so). Additionally, given that we are subject to very specific rules concerning the collection of personally identifying information through our website (names, email addresses, home address, financial information, etc.), we ask that you not use the comments portion of this blog to solicit this information from users of our website. We also ask that you not use the comments portion for advertising, and do not add to your comment links to other websites, as we cannot be responsible for the content on other websites. Finally, the ACLU cannot guarantee the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any information in the comment section and expressly disclaims any liability for any information in this section.